The Civic Node

The Untouchables — PBS Frontline

3 min read

Original source

Summary

PBS Frontline’s January 2013 documentary investigating why no senior Wall Street executive was arrested or prosecuted for the fraud leading to the 2008 financial crisis. The documentary obtained the defining public articulation of the Obama DOJ’s non-prosecution posture: DOJ Criminal Division chief Lanny Breuer told Frontline that what he’d seen was “abominable” but “not what makes a criminal case.” Two former high-level DOJ Criminal Division prosecutors told Frontline that when it came to Wall Street, “there were no investigations going on. There were no subpoenas, no document reviews, no wiretaps.”

Key Points

  • More than four years after the 2008 crisis, zero senior Wall Street executives had been arrested or prosecuted.
  • Breuer’s on-camera defense: “I am personally offended by much of what I’ve seen… But that is not what makes a criminal case. What makes a criminal case is that I can prove beyond a reasonable doubt every element of a crime.”
  • Two anonymous former DOJ Criminal Division prosecutors: “there were no investigations going on. There were no subpoenas, no document reviews, no wiretaps.” They reported Breuer was “overly fearful of losing.”
  • Citigroup Senior VP Richard Bowen reported internally that approximately 60% of loans didn’t meet Citi’s own underwriting policy by 2006, rising to over 80% by 2007. No prosecutions resulted.
  • Frontline located multiple whistleblowers who had never been interviewed by federal investigators — they were not hiding; they were simply never contacted.
  • Former NY AG Eliot Spitzer: “The Justice Department failed. They have not done what needed to be done.”

Newsletter Angles

  • Cross-partisan anchor for institutional gaslighting: the Obama DOJ on public record declining to investigate Wall Street. The pattern is not Trump-specific; it is structural. Pairs with the Holder Senate Judiciary testimony (two months later) to make the non-prosecution posture explicit institutional policy.
  • “Greed isn’t criminal” is the cleanest single-sentence articulation of the procedural-compliance-as-non-accountability frame. Useful as a direct quote when arguing that institutional architecture, not individual bad faith, produces impunity.
  • “No subpoenas, no document reviews, no wiretaps” is the operational proof that the investigation didn’t happen. It’s not that investigators tried and failed; they didn’t try.

Entities Mentioned

  • Lanny Breuer — DOJ Criminal Division Chief; primary on-camera subject
  • Eric Holder — Attorney General; Breuer’s superior; testified to Senate on “too big to jail” two months later
  • Eliot Spitzer — Former NY AG; on-camera critic
  • Barack Obama — President under whom the non-prosecution posture operated

Concepts Mentioned

Quotes

“I am personally offended by much of what I’ve seen. I think there was a level of greed, a level of excessive risk taking in this situation that I find abominable and I find very upsetting. But that is not what makes a criminal case.” — Lanny Breuer

“The Justice Department failed. They have not done what needed to be done.” — Eliot Spitzer

“There were no investigations going on. There were no subpoenas, no document reviews, no wiretaps.” — former DOJ Criminal Division prosecutors, to Frontline

Notes

Frontline, Jan 22, 2013. The “backtrack” coverage published separately by Frontline a month later is also worth noting: Holder and DOJ spokespeople attempted to walk back the “too big to jail” framing in subsequent weeks. The walk-back did not change the underlying enforcement pattern.

Graph View

Backlinks